Seven PJHL teams take league to B.C. Supreme Court after Cloverdale expansion team ruled ineligible for 2025–26 season.
Legal Challenge Emerges
Seven Pacific Junior Hockey League (PJHL) teams have filed a petition in B.C. Supreme Court, alleging the league acted “oppressively and unfairly” by cancelling the Cloverdale expansion team’s inaugural season.
How the Dispute Began
The PJHL had approved Cloverdale’s entry in April, with BC Hockey also granting approval soon after. But on September 2, league commissioner Trevor Alto informed teams that Cloverdale would not play in 2025–26, citing missing ownership details, arena agreements, and financial arrangements.
Why Teams Are Contesting the Decision
The Abbotsford Pilots, Aldergrove Ironmen, Mission City Outlaws, North Vancouver Wolf Pack, Port Moody Panthers, Surrey Knights and White Rock Whalers argue the exclusion stems from a failed March motion to split the league into two tiers. They believe Cloverdale’s removal punishes clubs that opposed the restructuring plan.
Where the Friction Lies
Court filings suggest Cloverdale would have joined the so-called “Tier 2” group alongside the petitioning teams, while eight others aimed to form a “Tier 1” division. The league insists the Cloverdale application never received the required two-thirds vote and points to conflicts of interest, including White Rock Whalers’ owner helping Cloverdale secure resources.
What the League Says
In its response, the PJHL maintains Cloverdale never officially joined, noting the absence of proper insurance and concerns about proposed owner Ronald Paterson, who has not presented a finalized plan or attended required meetings. The league also referenced a $750,000 franchise fee that was never finalized.
What Comes Next
The petitioners want the Cloverdale franchise reinstated immediately, arguing that its removal damages league stability and competitiveness. The PJHL counters that the issue stems from an internal vote, not misconduct. A court ruling on the matter will be made at a later date, leaving the fate of Cloverdale’s debut season uncertain.
This article is original and written specifically for Surreyspeak.com
